Physics for girls

physics for girls

 

← Back to Atomic Structure contents

ATOMIC STRUCTURE · CHAPTER 6 OF 12

How do we detect radiation?

A detector can register radiation that you cannot see. But some counts come from the surroundings—even when the source you are investigating has been removed. How do we separate those counts?

By the end, you’ll be able to…

  • describe how a Geiger–Müller tube and photographic film detect ionising radiation
  • identify natural and human-made sources of background radiation
  • calculate count rate and correct readings for background radiation
  • explain random fluctuations and how to improve measurements.

Detect the effect, not the invisible particle

Ionising radiation can remove electrons from atoms. Detectors turn the effects of these interactions into something we can measure: electrical pulses or a change in photographic film.

A Geiger–Müller tube, often called a GM tube, connects to a counter or rate meter. A registered event produces a pulse. The electronics may display a count or make a click.

ANIMATED DETECTOR EXPLORER

From radiation to a count

Watch radiation enter the Geiger–Müller tube. Each detected event produces a pulse and increases the count.

Positive central wire Thin window Negative outer casing Gas α Alpha particle + − + − + − Counter 0 1 2 3 4 5 6

How does the counter register radiation?

Radiation ionises the gas, producing electrons and positive ions. Electrons move towards the positive central wire, while positive ions move towards the negative casing, where they can gain electrons and become neutral again. The resulting electrical pulse is registered as one count.

* Simplified animation. The count repeats from 0 to 6; real radioactive events occur randomly.

Counts and count rate are different

A count is a registered detection. Count rate is the number of counts per unit time. A reading of 120 counts in 60 s gives 2 counts per second.

To calculate count rate:

Count rate = number of counts ÷ counting time

Use counts/s when the time is in seconds, or counts/min when it is in minutes. Always show the unit.

A detector count rate is not automatically the source’s activity in Bq. Some emissions miss the detector or are not registered, and background radiation can add counts.

Why does it count with no source nearby?

Background radiation is ionising radiation present in our surroundings. Removing the source being investigated does not remove radiation from rocks, the atmosphere, space or other sources.

▶ ANIMATED EXPLORER

Where does radiation come from?

Watch each object travel from left to right and pause beneath the scanner. Look at where the radiation particles originate.

RADIATION SCANNER
SOURCE EXPLAINED

Bananas

Bananas contain potassium, including a tiny amount of radioactive potassium-40.

Rocks

Some rocks contain naturally radioactive isotopes. Their unstable nuclei can decay.

Brickwork

Some bricks and other building materials contain naturally radioactive substances.

Flying

At high altitude, less atmosphere shields us from cosmic radiation, so exposure is greater.

Cosmic rays

Cosmic rays originate mainly from energetic processes beyond our Solar System and reach Earth's atmosphere.

Medical X-rays

X-ray machines produce ionising radiation for imaging. This is not natural background radiation.

Nuclear power

Nuclear reactors produce radiation during fission. Shielding and containment protect people outside.

* The scanner is imaginary. Pink particles are a simplified illustration of ionising radiation, not a literal representation of every type. Nuclear reactors are designed with shielding and containment.

Measure the background first

Measure background counts with the source removed or stored well away from the detector. Use a known counting time. Repeat the measurement, or collect counts for longer, to reduce the effect of random fluctuations on the estimated average rate.

Then measure with the source present, keeping the arrangement fixed. The total includes source detections and background detections.

To estimate the source’s contribution:

Corrected count rate = total count rate − background count rate

Convert both readings to the same time unit before subtracting. You are subtracting an estimate of the background rate, not identifying exactly which individual detections came from the source.

▶ INTERACTIVE MEASUREMENT LAB

What is the detector actually measuring?

Even without a radioactive source nearby, a Geiger–Müller tube can detect background radiation from the surroundings.

Select a stage to see what the GM tube measures. Compare the readings, then calculate the count rate due to the source alone.

Source removed · 60 s each
Reading 118
Reading 222
Reading 320
Mean background: 20 counts/min
Source present · 60 s each
Reading 1138
Reading 2142
Reading 3140
Mean total: 140 counts/min
GM TUBE AND COUNTER Source GM tube 20 140 counts/min GM counter Fixed distance

3 · Your turn: correct the reading

Total: 140 counts/min · Background: 20 counts/min

What is the estimated count rate due to the source alone?

Not quite. Subtract the background reading.
Correct! 140 − 20 = 120 counts/min.
Not quite. You need to subtract, not add.
Reveal the calculation

Corrected count rate = total − background

140 − 20 = 120 counts/min

120 ÷ 60 = 2 counts/s

* Illustrative measurements. Counts fluctuate randomly in real experiments. Background radiation cannot be switched off; the source is removed to measure it separately. The GM tube does not detect every emitted particle, so 2 counts/s is not necessarily an activity of 2 Bq.

INTERACTIVE READ THE EVIDENCE

Did the source suddenly change?

The same detector records background counts of 18, 22 and 20 in three equal one-minute intervals.

What is the best explanation of the different totals?
Try again. Small variations are expected; these data alone do not show a fault.
Correct. Individual detections occur at irregular times. Use repeated or longer readings to estimate an average rate.
Try again. The numbers rise and then fall. There is no steady increase.
Why measure for longer?

A longer interval usually collects more counts. Random variations are then a smaller fraction of the total, so the average rate is more reliable.

It does not make individual decays predictable or guarantee an identical result each time. If intervals differ, divide each count by its own counting time before comparing rates.

Three worked examples

Calculate count rate:

A radiation detector records 360 counts in 120 s. Calculate the count rate in counts per second.

Count rate = counts ÷ time

Count rate = 360 ÷ 120

Count rate = 3 counts/s

Calculate corrected count rate:

A GM tube measures a total count rate of 48 counts/s. The background count rate is 3 counts/s. Calculate the corrected count rate due to the radioactive source.

Corrected rate = total rate − background rate

Corrected rate = 48 − 3

Corrected rate = 45 counts/s

Calculate corrected count rate:

A detector records 600 counts in 2 minutes with a radioactive source present. The background count rate is 30 counts/min. Calculate the corrected count rate due to the source in counts per minute.

Corrected rate = (counts ÷ time) − background rate

Corrected rate = (600 ÷ 2) − 30

Corrected rate = 270 counts/min

Never subtract a background count collected over one time interval directly from a total count collected over a different interval. Convert to rates in matching units first.

Photographic film keeps a record of exposure

Ionising radiation can affect photographic film. After development, greater exposure produces more darkening under otherwise comparable conditions.

A film badge keeps film in a light-tight holder, so ordinary light does not expose it. Sections behind different filters help trained staff interpret exposure. Film records accumulated exposure over time; it does not provide an immediate count or a click for each event.

INTERACTIVE FILM EXPLORER

What changes after exposure?

Compare the developed film for lower and higher exposure. Assume the same radiation type, film and development conditions.

FILM BADGELight-tight holderAfter development
Lower exposure produces less darkening. A light patch does not prove that no radiation was present.
Higher exposure produces more darkening in this comparison. Film must be developed and interpreted; this is not a live detector display.

INTERACTIVE CHOOSE A DETECTOR

Which detector fits the job?

You need to compare count rates immediately as an absorber is added. Which is the better choice?
Correct. A GM tube provides pulses that can be counted during a known interval.
Try again. Film provides a record that is read after development, not an immediate count rate.
Try again. The devices provide different types of measurement.
When might a film badge be useful?

It can provide a record of a worker’s accumulated exposure over a monitoring period. It cannot warn the wearer instantly that the radiation level has just increased.

Make the comparison fair

  1. Measure background with the source removed or stored well away. Record the counting time.
  2. Position the source and detector at a fixed separation. Keep their orientation the same.
  3. Collect counts for a known interval. Repeat comparable readings or use a longer interval.
  4. Calculate rates using consistent units, then subtract the mean background rate.
  5. Change only the variable being investigated. For absorption, keep source distance and alignment fixed while changing the absorber.

* A real radioactive-source investigation is a supervised school activity with approved equipment and procedures. These models allow the measurements to be explored without a source.

INTERACTIVE QUICK CHECK

Check your understanding

Choose one answer for each question. Feedback appears underneath.

1. Why can a GM tube count when the test source is removed?
Try again. The detector registers interactions; it does not need to create radioactive nuclei.
Correct. Radiation from the surroundings can reach the detector.
Try again. Background counts are expected.
2. Total rate = 96 counts/min. Background = 24 counts/min. What is the corrected rate?
Try again. Subtract background rather than adding it.
Try again. Divide counts by time to find rates, but these values are already rates.
Correct. 96 − 24 = 72 counts/min.
3. What does a photographic film badge provide?
Correct. Radiation affects the film, which is developed and interpreted later.
Try again. Film does not provide a live count display.
Try again. Individual nuclear decay times cannot be predicted.
INTERACTIVE CHALLENGE

A student subtracts 40 background counts, collected over 2 minutes, from 180 total counts, collected over 1 minute. They report 140 counts/min from the source. Explain and correct the mistake.

Compare the counting times before subtracting. Suggest one way to improve the measurement.

Reveal the answer

The counts were collected over different times, so they cannot be subtracted directly.

Background rate = 40 ÷ 2 = 20 counts/min. Total rate = 180 ÷ 1 = 180 counts/min.

Corrected count rate = 180 − 20 = 160 counts/min.

Collect counts over a longer interval, or repeat readings and calculate an average rate, to reduce the relative effect of random fluctuations. Keep the source–detector arrangement fixed.

CHAPTER 6

Chapter summary

  • A GM tube detects radiation through ionisation of gas and produces electrical pulses.
  • Photographic film darkens after exposure and development; it records accumulated exposure.
  • Background radiation comes from natural and human-made sources.
  • Count rate = counts ÷ counting time.
  • Subtract background rate from total rate using matching units.
  • Random fluctuations are expected. Longer or repeated measurements improve estimates of average rates.
  • Detector count rate is not automatically the source’s activity.